Compliance is only the starting point
“We need a type approval. But why is that so relevant?” “Do you have a type approval? But for what exactly?” These are typical questions we’ve had during the more than 200 surveys we’ve completed in the last years.
The questions are valid, especially in the beginning when the first yachts caught fire due to lithium. Several companies stood up, quickly crafted storage solutions and without any guidance just supplied them to quite some vessels over the last years. It depended on who we spoke with on board: we had examples where captains weren’t interested because they didn’t see the possible issues but where the crew stood up to meet us, or situations where we met a crew which came recently on board since their previous vessel burned down. They just want to make sure it won’t happen again.
I’ve written this article to explain what this updated Amendment 1 of the MGN really is about, based on real experience on board. All solutions we provide to the industry are simply the best ones available. The issue is, some of these solutions are not type approved yet since they are generations ahead of the updated MGN version. We’ve been part of the initial review of the MGN-681 back in 2021-2022 and some of the updates we recommended back then are now taken into the update. So the companies creating new technology are years ahead of the legislation.
Lithium-ion systems are rapidly becoming standard onboard modern vessels, but they introduce a fundamentally different risk profile that is still not fully understood across the industry. Why is the market only talking about having a type approval, while this doesn’t give you anything in terms of on board safety, and compliance?
With the introduction of MGN 681 Amendment 1, important steps have been made. At the same time, we see a growing tendency to interpret compliance as safety, and to focus on isolated solutions rather than the full system.
I wrote this article to bring clarity from a practical, real-world perspective. Not just what is required, but what works onboard. And what can avoid incidents that are pretended not to exist. Because in lithium-ion safety, compliance is only the starting point.